Saturday, June 29, 2024
Home 2017-18-Vol3-Issue2 Lie Detector and Narco-Analysis Test Vis-À-Vis Right Against Self - Incrimination And...

Lie Detector and Narco-Analysis Test Vis-À-Vis Right Against Self – Incrimination And Other Fundamental Rights

EVIDENCE GATHERED BY ADMINISTERING NARCO-ANALYSIS TEST AND OTHER DDT’s IS SELFINCRIMINATING
EVIDENCE
The principle of self-incrimination was first introduced in the Fifth Amendment of the U.S. which states that “No person shall be compelled in any criminal case, to be a witness against himself”.2 In the 1886 case of Boyd v. United States,” the Supreme Court held that seizing or compelling production of a defendant’s private papers to be used in evidence against him was equivalent to compelling him to be a witness against himself.3
If an accused compel to provide evidence, it absolutely prohibited prosecution for any criminal transaction.4
In India, this principle comes under Art.20 (3)5 which is a fundamental canon of common law criminal jurisprudence.6

This Article is absolute in nature which means it cannot be suspended even in emergency. By 44th Amendment in 1978 Art. 20 has been granted a non-derogable status.7

2017-18-Vol3-Issue2-_17

Website | + posts
Raj Vishnoi
TAMILNADU NATIONAL LAW SCHOOL, TRICHY | + posts
RELATED ARTICLES

Gender Justice: A Comparative Study of U.K., U.S.A., E.U. and India

In most ancient societies women have been considered men’s inferiors physically and intellectually. Throughout most of ancient Greece and Rome, women enjoyed...

Unearthing the Elements of Privacy from the Information and Technology Act, 2000: Data Protection in India

“The right to privacy is inextricably bound up with all exercises of human liberty – both as it...

Right to Information – An Overview

Right to Information Act, 2005 can be considered to be one of the most reformative and ambitious legislations...

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisment -

Most Popular

RAPE AND INDIAN PENAL CODE: A WAY FORWARD FOR A GENDER – JUST SOCIETY

The Indian Penal Code which was drafted by Lord T.B. Macaulay and his law commissioners in 1860 criminalizes rape as a coercive...

REALIZING GENDER JUSTICE IN MARITAL OBLIGATIONS : EVALUATION OF JUDICIAL TREND IN INDIA

Women’s rights within a family can be construed only by conceptualizing the term ‘family’ and the myriad forms...

JUDICIAL TRENDS OF SENTENCING CAPITAL PUNISHMENT IN INDIA : A CROSS-SECTIONAL ANALYSIS

“The gallows is not a machine of death but a symbol, symbol of terror, cruelty and irreverence for...

THE HUMAN RIGHTS AND REFUGEE CRISIS: ANALYZING THE INTERNATIONAL LAW AND POLITICAL FORTITUDE

In the last two years world witnessed the biggest humanitarian and refugee crisis in the history of mankind. The civil war and...

Recent Comments